Yeast Pitching Rates, an experiment

Experimental Brew DayI am not a scientist, but have used test and measurement to good effect in my career. After reviewing my APAV2 notes, it appears that I under pitched by a significant factor. I intentionally pitched at the same rate as the previous brew to eliminate variables other than brewing liquor, however, it stalled and took a bit of teasing to rouse and finish fermentation. It finished very high. So, I really took a hard look at the online pitching calculators, as well as the instructions from Wyeast, White Labs and Fermentis, and frankly, what the heck I was thinking pitching so low in the first place!

I prefer dry yeast, because of the convenience and costs, however I am familiar with building starters up from single vials to the proper pitching counts. I don’t want to mislead you. There is something mentally difficult for me to pay for 4-5 vials of liquid yeast to pitch, so starters are required, and for a 10 gallon batch, I have to usually make 2-3 steps. Yuck. I plan ahead, brewing a starter just requires more advanced planning – and a long trip to the LHBS.

Proposed is that a Belgian Dubbel with a very simple grain bill, and just high enough to skew out of the “1 sachet of dry yeast per 5 gallons of 1.040 gravity beer” realm to help me wiggle out some objective data out of subjective observation. I want to see EXACTLY what happens when you closely follow recommended pitching rates, intentionally under pitch and intentionally massively over pitch. I split a 3 gallon BIAB batch into individual fermenters, and VERY carefully weighed out the dry yeast into the appropriate gram weights. I rehydrated at 10X the weight and pitched warmish – at 86F. I am fermenting warm in general in the low 70s to add more stress.

I am already seeing results, all three batches are showing activity in less than 2 hours, with the over pitch showing significant krausen! Turns out that if you follow instructions, good things happen, at least with yeast.

My hope is that in about a month and half, I can pull together a few people to do blind tasting, and get some empirical information about pitching rates. Ok empirical only about this batch under these conditions on this yeast… but still… good data.

Leave a Reply